|
Post by Heather on Jan 24, 2009 21:39:16 GMT -5
There is a thread on TNS debating the most over-rated and under-rated sum41 and I thought it would be a good ASB discussion so lets hear you thoughts....
Sum41 OR: - tht, never wake up & anic - pointless in my opinion, but fans seem to go crazy for them, personally they are just noise to me UR: - best of me - one of the most artistic songs for sum and they don't even get to play it live - heart attack - fun lyrics, young vibe, hardly played and less time recognized
Avril OR: - complicated - aside from being the first single its not as good as the number of times its played on the radio - girlfriend - addictive and catchy, unfortunatly UR: - how does it feel - don't know why it doesn't get the status of the other ballads - naked - I like to think of it as the forgotten track of let go, it just never seems to get played live.
Evan OR: - BYOOL or so suddenly - everyone always talks about these songs, but there not even the best ones UR: - fear - my fave ET song the beat and melody is KICK ASS, plus hello guitar bridge solo
|
|
gisele
Walking Disaster
Posts: 10
|
Post by gisele on Jan 29, 2009 11:02:09 GMT -5
Awesome idea! In my opinion:Avril LavigneOver-rated:Keep Holding On & When You're Gone - pretty boring to me, Innocence is way better than these 2 songs, i dont even know why they included KHO on TBDT. "I Will Be" is way more emotional. Under-rated:Together/Forgotten - To me those are the best songs when it comes to the melody, but no, MHE had to be a single Tomorrow/Naked - best songs regarding the lyrics, Tomorrow kinda got some attention, but Naked NEVER did. Evan TaubenfeldOver-rated:BYOOL - i've had it with this song lol everyone talks so much about it, but come on, even the 30 seconds of 'Pumpkin Pie" we've heard is cooler than that. Or lyricaly, The World Keeps Turning and Cin&Van are way better too. BYOOL's lyrics are just typical, the other ones mentioned aren't. Under-rated:Fear - my fav off "Just Sign Here", also, the only up beat song Evan was able to put off on this record. The melody is real fun, makes me wanna jump and start singing it! lol SlowRocker - there's just something so beautifully dark on this song, Ev's voice matches it perfectly, kinda rough. Quitter - Also an awesome song. that awesome bass in the begging, then followed by drums and guitar, are breath taking for me lol my fav Evan song so far Weak Night's - ha! this is one is kinda the same "style" as BYOOL, and to me it's a hundred percent better. it's just beautifully raw, in some ways. Sum 41Over-rated:Fat Lip/The Hell Song - got way too much attention than lots of better songs at the time, like, Summer, Handle This or No Brains March Of The Dogs - this song got so much attention at the beggining of the Underclass Hero era...but, it's like, my least fav song of the record, the lyrics are awesome, but it doesnt beat lots of their own songs. Under-rated: Speak Of The Devil/Dear Father/Best Of Me/CAFIMT - just awesome songs, that should've deserved more attention Angles With Dirty Faces - the drums in the beggining says it all lol and i also agree with lots os the things fenderrocks said, like, with Heart Attack
|
|
|
Post by Heather on Feb 11, 2009 19:47:39 GMT -5
I think I'm going to add " Falling into History" and " Tomorrow You Didn't" to my Avril list
|
|
|
Post by tsuua on Feb 12, 2009 0:06:37 GMT -5
^for ORs or URs?
|
|
|
Post by Heather on Feb 12, 2009 14:52:56 GMT -5
both??? lol
|
|
|
Post by tsuua on Feb 13, 2009 2:20:39 GMT -5
lol that's what I would have thought.. I'll try to come up with a list myself too, but it's just really hard. I'm the biggest trouble when it comes to underrating and overrating the songs..lol
|
|